| Question ID 2817 - Quran - 2015-09-20 08:00:02 |
| Salam un alike
1)It is mentioned in the Noble Quran, (It is you we worship and you we ask for help). When we say (Ya Ali Madad) we are basically seeking help from other then Allah (SWT) could you point some evidence from the Quran/Hadis/books that saying (Ya ali Madad) is not shirk to say?
2)is there any prove from the Holy Quran that our Prophet and Imams (as) were Shia? Thankyou |
| |
Answer:- FW: disgrace to Islam and Arabs
M
Yesterday
*Mahmood Abdulla*
http://www.awdnews.com/top-news/saudi-foreign-minister-we-are-in-dire-need-of-israeli-military-
Ya Ali Madad
M
Mohammed Musawi
to me
22 hours ago
Details
This message has been modified to fit your screen. Tap here to show
original.
*Ya Ali MadadID:* 2667
*Category:* Non Shia Q&A
Question:What is the authenticity of saying YA ALI MADAD..Sunnis say that
it is shirk? Please do give ur reply with authentic Hadith or quran as I
have to give this reply to sunni people..jazak Allah.Answer: Saying (Ya Ali
Madad) is seeking the Waseela of Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib (a.s.) to get your
wish from Allah (s.w.t.). Those who misunderstand it think something else
and put allegation on Muslims wrongly. Seeking help from human beings is
not shirk. Don't you read in the Holy Quran how Prophet Sulaiman (Solomon)
(a.s.) sought help of others to bring the throne of Bilqis? All other
prophets sought help from people but never believed or claimed them to be
God or His partners. We seek help from doctors when we need them and indeed
nobody can say that it is shirk. What if we seek help from the best of the
servants of Allah (s.w.t.) and seek their Waseela and intervention to pray
for us to Allah (s.w.t.)? In the Holy Qur?an, Allah (s.w.t.) has ordered us
to seek help from patience (sabr) and prayers (salat) (The Holy Quran, 2:45
and 2:153).Obviously, Sabr and Salat are not Allah, but still we must seek
help from them. Saying (Ya Ali Madad) is therefore, absolutely in
accordance with the Holy Quran and the Prophetic Ahadeeth. Even in Sunni
books there is authentic Hadeeths that the Prophet (SAWA) taught a blind
man to pray Salat and say in Sojood (Ya Mohammad) and this Salat was
practiced by Muslim safter the life of the Prophet (SAWA) as it is narrated
from Othman Bin Hunaif who taught it to a man who had a need to meet Uthman
Bin Affan during his government. No doubt, saying Ya Mohammad is same like
saying Ya Ali Madad. Wassalam Mohammad al-Musawi
Sent from my iPad
Reply
Forward
statement on Yaum-ul Arafah and Eid-ul Adha
M
Yesterday
Raana, me (4)
Please give sometime to edit it. On Saturday, September 19, 2015, Raana
Bokhari
On Sunday, September 13, 2015, abbass Reply-To: <
wabil1895232@wabil.com> wrote:
> Mr/Mrs abbass
> posted a new question on wabil website, the details are below...
> Category : Quran
> Question : Salam un alike
>
> 1)It is mentioned in the Noble Quran, (It is you we worship and you we ask
> for help). When we say (Ya Ali Madad) we are basically seeking help from
> other then Allah (SWT) could you point some evidence from the
> Quran/Hadis/books that saying (Ya ali Madad) is not shirk to say?
>
> 2)is there any prove from the Holy Quran that our Prophet and Imams (as)
> were Shia? Thankyou
>
>
|
| |
|
